Gentlemen,
I'm thinking about buying a boat. I'm not looking for a fancy expensive one, just a nice boat that can fish most of Michigan's inland muskie waters (Murray, Ovid, Campau, T'apple mostly). Was wondering if anyone had any suggestions on brands, types (Deep V, Jon boats etc), lengths, or places to look (beside the sport show this weekend).
Joel
Jason, I know where a Tuffy Esox Magnum is sitting that is about 8 years ols and has never seen any gas in the tank. The boat is new as far as I know. Its a 17 foot with a 60 hp Susuki 4 stroke. The motor has zero hours on it. Last I heard he wanted about 10 grand which is cheap for that boat.
Now I,ll tell you, My little 1448 Sea Ark jon boat gets it done on most any lake in the lower pen. The little 9.9 merc is all the motor I need unless I have to fish big water . We set it up nice for casting and trolling. I picked it up for 2500.00 with the trailor almost new. I would look in that direction. I can fish all day with that boat for a couple buck in gas. I even pullit with our little tiney Chevy Aveo car. get near 30 mpg pulling the boat. That is as cheap a ride as I have seen out there today. This lets us fish a lot more than if we had to haul our starcraft around. Mike
King has a good point there. After my bass boat I had an x-wide 16.5 foot jon boat that was a sweet boat with a 25hp on it (we called it the Lilly Pad). It had a big front deck with a custom livewell/deck extension that was intended to keep tournament bass alive but it even had a 52" muskie in it one day. It was perfect for anything and had tons of room. It was also sweet for this side of the state because it was awesome on the Grand and the Muskegon for Steelhead. We caught some big muskies out of that boat and won a bunch of money in bass tournaments too… some days I really miss it… tons of great memories in that boat during the couple years I owned it.
I saw those Tuffy boats at the OH musky show and they were pretty nice. It would probably help if we knew what type of budget you are working with and what vehicle you would be towing your boat with (what's the maximum towing capacity). The tow capacity of your vehicle may limit the weight of the boat you are looking for. At the MMA events try to check out everyone's boat and ask them what they like and what they don't like.
You will get more bang for your buck with a used boat and the Tuffy boat mentioned seems like a good deal but you need to be careful and take the boat on the water and have the motor inspected. I bought a new boat from Cabelas and it is a 16.5' Alumacraft (see link) with a 50 hp and in hindsight I wish I had gotten a slighter bigger boat. I never thought that I would want to fish on Lake St. Clair but now I do go out on it but only when the weather is very good.
You need to look at the long term and what you will use the boat for and will you have kids that you want to take waterskiing? How many people will you want in the boat? I believe you are fairly young and this may be the only boat you get for a while so do some good research.
As for buying the boat I would look at both used and new and the more you look the more you will narrow it down. Unfortunately, the automotive business is down and a lot of guys are selling their toys pretty cheap. Bad for them and maybe good for you and once you know what you are looking for you may want to post it here and people can let you know if they see anything that fits your needs. Good luck!
My boat (2004) version:
<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 165-cs.php">[Permission to view this media is denied]
Good links:
<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
">[Permission to view this media is denied]
<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
l=1&w=24&p=38&f=5692&gc=MR>c=MR&ml=D"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … tc=MR&ml=D">[Permission to view this media is denied]
l=1&w=24&p=38&f=5692&gc=MR>c=MR&ml=D
<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 19,00.html">[Permission to view this media is denied]
Got mine off ebay for 1200.00,went to IND to get it,but it was a great purchase!IMO.
I must say,spring and early summer are usually a bad time to buy as prices tend to be higher,but there are alot of broke people in Mich that are looking to unload stuff.Im sure you will find a sweet deal if you look around. [smilie=2c.gif]
with gas prices pushing 4 bucks a gallon. My 115 Merc wont get much time this year. I might run 60 gallons thru it all year.
Ill fish way more days with the Little Jon and it wont hurt my pocket book. In my opinion it has been the best Musky fishing investment that Michelle and I made. With the little car and boat even at 4 bucks a gallon I can fill the boat with 12 bucks and put 30 in the car and go most anywhere I want in lower Michigan. If I try that with my Starcraft I have to stay at the lake for a week to justify the cost of pulling that boat to the lake.
These high gas prices are going to hurt guys with big boats and big tow vehicles. I sure hope we get some relief from those prices before Musky season. Like Will says a 16 foot long extra wide Jon or the shorter 1448 like mine is a real good choice for all around fishing. We use ours for rivers, lakes and even can carry it short distances if we have to for lakes without launches. Good luck with your search. Ill keep my eyes on the paper and see if something pops up over this way. Mike and Michelle
I've been looking quite a bit at the jon boat option. Beeing a teacher who drives an Impala, my budget and towing capabilities are limited. My only concern with this option is if in a few years I'll want something bigger to fish the larger lakes. Is it worth investing a little more money now on a bigger boat, or stick with the convenient but smaller jon boat?
and just to let everyone know….I'm Joel and my little brother is Jason. We're easily confused, being two good looking guys and all, but Jay is still my little runt brother
I had a 16 foot Smoker Craft open semi deep V side counsil powered by a 40 hp Merc 2 stroke. It was not much better than the 1448 Jon though it did better on windy days on lakes like Thornapple. I almost drowned on Lake St Clair with that boat. I also almost got into trouble in Lake Michigan with it. We decided that owning two boats was a better choice.
We started with the 18 foot deep V Starcraft , full wind shield and 115 Merc 4 stroke. Its big and has a extra high bow for busting big waves. Its a big water boat but in a smaller package. We weathered some nasty weather on St. Clair in 2006 with that boat. Its down fall for these days is the fact that it eats 10 gallons per day if we troll with it. The 30 gallon tank cost 100.00 to fill and the worst part is pulling it. I have to use our 1 ton van or our 4wd Dodge truck to pull it safely. Just a trip to Austin for me in that boat cost us 50 to 70 bucks in tow vehichle gas. So we save the big boat for trips where we are going to stay at a certain lake for a week or more.
The 9.9 engine on the little boat is very stingy on gas. I can troll all day on 2.5 gallons. If I mix casting and trolling I get almost three days fishing on one 3 gallon tank. On lakes like Murray High winds dont bother me as that lake always has a calm area to fish. Thornapple can get bumpy but I have never had to come in because of big waves there.
We had to get the little boat because if we didnt we would have had to pass on many days on the water due to lack of gas money. I think the 2500 bucks was the best investment I ever made in a fishing tool. I know most folks try to get one boat that does it all but I have not seen that boat yet.. Mike
Now you guys have me dreading the thought of pulling my pontoon around. But its the only thing that will fit the whole crew and thier freinds.
All I have to do is whisper muskie and I have at least 5 kids lined up and ready to go. Ahhh what am I thinking? Its worth every penny!!!! [smilie=2thumbsup.gif]
That still is a nice rig Mike and Michelle have going.
I am guessing that your max towing would be around 1000-1200 lbs and buying a truck that tows more isn't a viable option. The future is hard to predict and I know that I wish I had bought a boat a step up from mine. It still boils down to how much you want to spend. Think about this:
1) You can go with the Jon boat option and not sink a lot of money in it and probably upgrade later to a bigger boat with minimum loss because you haven't dropped a bunch of money. You can also add on things like a good trolling motor, fishfinder/gps and transfer those items to the other boat later.
2) You could bite the bullet and get a bigger boat and realize this is the boat you will own for a long time. You may want to just get the boat and add all the accessories as you can afford to buy them. In hindsight I would have bought a boat at least 17' with a 75-90 HP motor similar to this:
<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … -specs.php">[Permission to view this media is denied]
Other thoughts:
-Do you have a buddy/brother that could split the cost with you? I know partnerships can be difficult but it would enable you to get the boat you want and split any insurance, registration and misc. fees.
-Make sure whatever you get has a decent resale value (Check NADA) so that if you have to sell it you don't take a beating.
Keep looking and asking questions and the more you research you do the better choice you will make. By the way I translated the fact that your a teacher as code for,"I can fish all summer"…..
Here's a couple pics of what I bought last August, and I love it so far! Tracker Pro Guide V-16; went for ~12.5k with a carbureted 2-stroke Merc 50. I can push it UP my slightly inclined driveway into my garage, ALONE. It's a breeze to trailer, launch and has a very shallow draft, while retaining lots of comfort and space for fishing. I don't plan on using it in big water much, if at all, and then only very near-shore.
If you see my car at the ramp, look for me out on the lake (prolly in the wrong place for muskies)! My car is often the only one that's not a pick-'em-up truck in the parking lot… unless Mike's Aveo is there, too. 🙄 Plate says, "CHEMI".
"><url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 3small.jpg">[Permission to view this media is denied]
” alt=”
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 3small.jpg">[Permission to view this media is denied]
” />
"><url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]<url url="[Permission to view this media is denied]
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 1small.jpg">[Permission to view this media is denied]
” alt=”
"><link_text text="[Permission to view this media is denied] … 1small.jpg">[Permission to view this media is denied]
” />
Honestly as far as boats go I have been seriously toying with the idea of getting rid of my Lund… Serious blasphemy in many circles but when I bought it I really liked fishing a particular type of water, now it occurs to me that nine times out of ten I dont need that much boat. I find myself wishing I had a 16 – 17 ft Jon boat rigged light that hauls azzz when needed. For where I fish it would be better suited so the question becomes do I sell it? or do I add to the fleet? The latter would result in me living in one of the vessels ALONE [smilie=ballchain.gif] as I dont think it would be well received. So the lesson from one teacher to another is think long and hard about where you will spend most of your time and as a mechanic GET A FOUR STROKE in a few years time the savings in gas will pay for the difference, seriously.
Kevin
Joel,
The best advice I can give you is try and fish with as many people as possilbe and notice what features of their boats are most important to you and then make your decision based on that. Then later on you won't have to add to it or regret not getting exactly what you wanted.
You and Jason are more than welcome to come fish Austin with me this year and fish out of my Tracker V-16. It is a 1997 but works for me. You can even run the show and I will fish out of the back of the boat.
Tom
How big is your Lund? Mine's only 16.5', and if anything, I feel cramped a bit.
As for gas, I don't use much out on Ovid (no-wake only, and I cast mostly), and I maybe burned 25 gal from end of Aug to Nov 5th with fairly heavy use (~2x week avg) with my 50hp. Plus, a 4-stroke is more complex (has a valve-train), is heavier, and needs more maintenance (oil changes, etc.). I'm thinking the sweet-spot for motors would be the injected 2-strokes (like the Merc Optimax line) for efficiency/simplicity/weight/durability.
But what do I know! [smilie=biggrin.gif]
I have a 16' 3" boat but it is tiller which makes a huge difference. It is 86" wide with vertical sidewalls and all open floor. Dont get me wrong I love it, but I have to tow it with something that gets less than 15 to the gallon due to its weight. As for the four stroke issue – you have to factor in the price of two-cycle oil in the mix- plus the inefficiency of running them below a certain rpm I have owned prolly' 30 different outboards and as many boats in my life and I would not go two-cycle by choice ever again. Many manufacturers have tried to clean up the 2 strokes but at low rpm the flow/vaporization/atomization of the fuel air mix just doesnt work as efficiently as an overhead cam 4 valves per cylinder four stroke this is largely due to the small exhaust chamber not allowing for a proper resonance wave to assist scavenging, I wont take that further unless someone is really interested. Honda has made four stroke outboards since the early 80's possibly late seventies and they are still around. Actual cost of maintenance is minimal, two quarts of oil and a $10 dollar filter ever 50 hours of run time, compare that to 20 something a gallon two stroke plus a thirty to fourty percent lower fuel consumption and it really does make sense PLUS —BIA certified oils, those for use in outboards have additives that make the emissions sink so as to prevent the "skimming" or rainbow effect that is so lovely on the water. So all the two stroke emitted underwater is little carbon footprints drifting slowly to the eutrophic joy of the lake.
Sorry not ranting AT you just a subject of interest to me…
SOOooooooo four cycles really have lower overall cost of operation, less noise, no smoke, waaaayyy smoother at all speeds, environmentally friendlier than two strokes but do outweigh them by about 150 to 200#s for a similar HP unit. For me definitely worth the trade plus in cold weather (25F and lower) they will actually continue to run correctly once warmed up, something my 2 strokes are not fond of (I still have 2 occasional users).
So that is my [smilie=2c.gif] [smilie=2c.gif] [smilie=2c.gif]
on that 🙄 🙄 FWIW
Kevin
Joel, I have a Tracker grizzly 15' 6'' with a 25hp merc that I love. Its fished every lake except the big lake. Great on gas, easy to tow, and you can launch anywhere. Plus I river fish so its great.
Also having a brother that fishes we have talked about all our boat purchases. He bought the bigger water boat, I have the small lake river boat. We trade off often when needed. You just got to get that brother out of school and making some money. [smilie=2thumbsup.gif]
Oooo, Kevin! Do I sense an engineer? 😀 Resonance waves; scavenging; we need to share some beers and discuss it some time!
As for 2-cycle oil, you can get some pretty cheap if you look around (Meijer had a good sale last fall, e.g.), and I've used less than a quart since I've had my boat, not counting the extra pre-mix they had me using during the 10-hour break-in period, so it seems they use even less than a 50:1 mix equivalent nowadays through the injectors. If your 2-strokes are more than a few years old, you may be surprised how much better they've gotten recently, especially the new F/E ones. But what do I know! 🙄
Anyway, when I bought, I was minimizing MONEY SPENT more than optimizing anything else, but smallness and general utility were important, too. That's why I got a small deep-V instead of a bass boat, since I thought it'd be marginally better in heavier seas than a bass boat, yet still would have a nice shallow draft and good maneuverability. So far, I haven't been disappointed.
"Cyberlunge" said:
I have a 16' 3" boat but it is tiller which makes a huge difference. It is 86" wide with vertical sidewalls and all open floor. Dont get me wrong I love it, but I have to tow it with something that gets less than 15 to the gallon due to its weight. As for the four stroke issue – you have to factor in the price of two-cycle oil in the mix- plus the inefficiency of running them below a certain rpm I have owned prolly' 30 different outboards and as many boats in my life and I would not go two-cycle by choice ever again. Many manufacturers have tried to clean up the 2 strokes but at low rpm the flow/vaporization/atomization of the fuel air mix just doesnt work as efficiently as an overhead cam 4 valves per cylinder four stroke this is largely due to the small exhaust chamber not allowing for a proper resonance wave to assist scavenging, I wont take that further unless someone is really interested. Honda has made four stroke outboards since the early 80's possibly late seventies and they are still around. Actual cost of maintenance is minimal, two quarts of oil and a $10 dollar filter ever 50 hours of run time, compare that to 20 something a gallon two stroke plus a thirty to fourty percent lower fuel consumption and it really does make sense PLUS —BIA certified oils, those for use in outboards have additives that make the emissions sink so as to prevent the "skimming" or rainbow effect that is so lovely on the water. So all the two stroke emitted underwater is little carbon footprints drifting slowly to the eutrophic joy of the lake.
Sorry not ranting AT you just a subject of interest to me…SOOooooooo four cycles really have lower overall cost of operation, less noise, no smoke, waaaayyy smoother at all speeds, environmentally friendlier than two strokes but do outweigh them by about 150 to 200#s for a similar HP unit. For me definitely worth the trade plus in cold weather (25F and lower) they will actually continue to run correctly once warmed up, something my 2 strokes are not fond of (I still have 2 occasional users).
So that is my [smilie=2c.gif] [smilie=2c.gif] [smilie=2c.gif]
on that 🙄 🙄 FWIW
Kevin
Kevin,
"150-200#s for a similar HP unit" 😯 …….It's not 1992 anymore, a Yamaha F150 four stroke weighs 466lbs. a Yamaha 150 two stroke weighs 426lbs., a Mercury 115 four stroke weighs 400lbs. a Mercury 115 Optimax (two stroke) weighs 375lbs. pretty comparible for the most part.
Unless you get a Verado which looks like an Orca sitting on your transom [smilie=biggrin.gif]
57
46
1 Guest(s)
