My experiences, especially lately, have been horrible! I had some nice stuff for sale/auction to. I usually put 2 big name lures with one not so big name lure and sold them in lots. Very reasonable pricing I thought. Be prepared to lose around 60+ cents on the dollar, and no matter how many times you put "want to sell as a lot" there will be guys emailing you to sell just one lure. Wish I didn't need some quick cash a few weeks ago because I took a beating and sold some really nice lures. [smilie=bangtard.gif]
Muskies first and EBAY were the sites I used to sell my stuff.

I've traded/sold quite a few baits and even reels the last year or two on Muskies First and have had nothing but good experiences doing so. It's a good way to buy/sell just a bait or two also without getting killed with fees or shipping charges. I would try there first.