This is one area when there is no Ford/Chevy/Dodge type debate. Sell the Gander Gift certificates or save them for something else.

Goodyear Marathons are the only trailer tire you should consider. There's a reason Ranger and Triton only put Marathons on their trailers, they're the best. My current trailer came with a set of Carlisles and I wore them out in just over a year. Yes, I put a lot of miles on a trailer and need the best or I'll just wear them out. The pros at Belle Tire said there's only one answer, I replaced them with Marathons and have three seasons on these and they still look great.

I would probaly go with the Carlisle;s with no other choice. Also make sure you run nearly full pressure as recommended and do a cheap alignment. Measure your axle from the corner of the trailer on both sides and make sure it is square. My old trailer would shift occassionaly from crappy launches and rocks…and trees…and other stuff 😕
Kevin

Don't buy the Carlisles! I have had them on my trailer for the past four years. I have gotten a blow out EVERY year. I talked with a trailer dealer in the area and he stated that Carlisles are garbage and blow everytime it gets warm outside. I think they are dangerous. I have replacing them this year. dr